Penwell Turner Funeral Home - Shelby, Ohio

Terri Lynn Fagan

Terri Lynn Fagan, age 66, of Shelby died Sunday, December 11, 2022 at OhioHealth Mansfield Hospital following a brief and unexpected illness.

Terri was born November 11, 1956 in Shelby to the late Robert “Gene” and Marjorie “Marge” (Pugh) Fagan and was a 1975 graduate of Shelby High School. After graduation, she worked at AMF until its closing, moving then to work at Corpad Co. in Mansfield, until ultimately working for Enman Stamping in Mansfield where she was currently employed.

Terri was a sports fanatic. She played in many golf, bowling, and softball leagues over the years- playing for Phil’s Place softball team for many seasons. She thoroughly enjoyed watching The Ohio State Buckeyes, Cleveland Indians, and Cleveland Browns.

Survivors include her siblings: Cheryl Sykes of Bucyrus, Deb Williams of Shelby, Brenda (Sid) Fields of Mansfield, and Michael Fagan of Shelby; special friend: Kim McNeeley and her son: Billy; and numerous nieces, nephews, other relatives, and friends. In addition to her parents, Terri was preceded in death by her brother-in-law: Larry Williams.

Family and friends are welcome on Thursday, December 15, 2022 from 5-7 pm at the Penwell Turner Funeral Home, 168 West Main Street, Shelby, where funeral services will be held Friday, December 16, 2022 at 10:30 am. Pastor Russ Smith will officiate and burial will follow in Oakland Cemetery, Shelby. Memorial contributions may be made to Shelby Helpline Ministries, 29 ½ Walnut Street, Shelby, OH 44875.

Online condolences may be made on Terri’s obituary at or on the funeral home’s Facebook page,

Memories & Condolence

  1. Mindy Utz says:

    My deepest condolences.

  2. Jackie Ingram Gonzalez says:

    I have so many great memories growing up with the my aunt Brenda and her family !! Sending you all love hugs and prayers from me and my family. Jackie, Dominic, Celeste, Nancy and Joe

  3. Karen Sheridan says:

    So sorry for your loss

  4. Cathy Esterline says:

    So sorry to hear of Terri’s passing. We grew up playing softball, bowling, and playing cards. I knew her for a long time. I was saddened to hear this. May she rest in peace. You will be missed.

  5. Margie Hoover says:

    so very sorry for the loss of Terri. Hugs and prayers for all the family. you have my deepest sympathy.

  6. Barbara Kaple says:

    to Terri’s family – I am so sorry for your loss. She was such a sweet person and I know you will miss her. Barb & Jan

  7. Terri Brown says:

    To all who knew and loved Terri. She worked for us at Enman Stamping for many years. Her energy and dedication will truly be missed. May you all find peace in remembering her smile and remembering all the good times you shared with her. She is at peace with our Heavenly Father.

  8. Joni Young says:

    Sorry to hear of the passing of a great classmate
    Ran into to her many times at grocery store
    Always friendly and had a smile! My sincere sympathy to her family and friends

  9. Tammy Rock says:

    My deepest heartfelt sympathy to you all.

  10. Brenda says:

    Im so sorry to hear Terri was a wonderful person and definitely will be missed so sad we love you Terri

  11. Ann Shepherd says:

    Prayers of comfort to Terri’s loved ones. I enjoyed playing softball with her, especially when our Dads coached Phil’s.

  12. Terri (Perman) DeVito says:

    Deb and family, remembering all the great times in girls softball! Thoughts and prayers to you and your family!

  13. Fred Fagan says:

    So sorry to hear of Terri’s passing she was a great cousin and always enjoyed spending time with her back in the day. Condolences to the Fagan family.

  14. Vicki (Bonecutter) Wicker says:

    My sincere condolences to Terri’s friends and family. I played many years of softball with her growing up. What a great player she was! I remember her as always so funny and happy! May your many fond memories far outweigh the sorrow you are feeling at this difficult time.

  15. Lora Brown says:

    My sincere condolences to the family, thinking of Terri brings back HAPPY memories of our softball games. We had so much fun! Terri would laugh at me because i use to tell her she rolled up her cigarettes on her arm like a man. Terri had a great sense of humor. I will miss u Terri. You always made me laugh! The world definitely needs more humor. We could go years and then bump into each other and catch up in few minutes like we never stopped talking. Sending u a big hug ! I will miss you.

  16. Veronica sheaffer says:

    So sorry for all of you. Terri will be missed by many. I wish I could be with you all today, but I am at home extremely sick. I love you all and give many hugs and prayers to you all

  17. Diane Sinclair says:

    I lost contact with Terri after leaving Enman. Shocked and saddened to learn of her passing. She was a good friend and will be severely missed. Condolences to her family.

  18. Lisa Crain Greene says:

    To all of you Fagan kids. I remember the fun times we had playing Ghost in the Graveyard and all the Tag games when we were kids. Terri was so easy going and nice to hang out with. She never cheated and was always smiling. I will miss her. So sorry for your loss.

  19. Suzanne Dilworth says:

    I used to work with Terri at School specialty back in 1999-2000. She was wonderful to work with, always looked forward to seeing her. She was a very sweet person. My condolences to her family.

  20. Tina Mckinney (Rogers) says:

    So sorry for your loss hooty and I have many good memories of our childhood! Terry was always fun

Leave Message or Express Your Condolence